Ahrefs Webmaster Tools vs Google Search Console

Disclosure: Some links to SEO tools on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. Several of these guides tell you to buy a cheaper tool, or none at all.
Both are free. Both require you to verify that you own the site. Both are described as "SEO tools", which has convinced a lot of people that they overlap and you only need one.
They barely overlap at all. One tells you what Google did with your site. The other tells you what the web thinks of it. Running both takes an afternoon to set up and covers most of what a small site needs — which is why the paid-tool question can usually wait.
What each one actually answers
| Question | Search Console | Ahrefs Webmaster Tools |
|---|---|---|
| What queries do I appear for? | Yes — real data | Estimated |
| How many clicks did I get? | Yes | No |
| Which pages did Google refuse to index, and why? | Yes | No |
| Who links to me? | A basic list | Yes — properly |
| Which of my pages are technically broken? | Partly | Yes — full crawl |
| How often does Googlebot visit? | Yes (Crawl stats) | No |
| Competitor data | No | No |
Read the last row twice. Neither free tool shows you competitors. That is the entire reason paid SEO tools exist, and it is the only honest argument for buying one.
Google Search Console: the only source of truth
Search Console is not a competitor to anything. It is Google telling you, directly, what it did with your pages. No third-party tool can replicate it because the data does not exist outside Google.
Four reports matter and the rest can wait:
Performance
Real queries, real impressions, real clicks, real average position. Filter to queries where you rank 5–15 and have impressions — those are pages one good edit away from traffic. This is the single highest-value screen in free SEO.
Pages (indexing)
Which URLs are indexed and, more importantly, which are not and why. "Discovered — currently not indexed" means Google knows the URL and has not bothered to crawl it. "Crawled — currently not indexed" means it looked and declined. Those two statuses tell you very different things, and both are invisible in every paid tool.
Crawl stats
How often Googlebot visits and what it fetched. If this number is tiny relative to your page count, nothing else you do to those pages matters yet.
URL Inspection
Check one URL's exact status, see the rendered HTML Google holds, and request indexing. Requests are rate-limited to roughly ten a day, so spend them on pages that deserve it.
If you are not reading Search Console weekly, buying a $139 tool will not help. It will just give you more numbers to not read.
Ahrefs Webmaster Tools: the free half of an expensive tool
AWT is free and works only on sites you own and have verified. It gives you two things Search Console does not.
A real backlink profile
Search Console's links report is a courtesy — a flat list with little context. AWT gives you Ahrefs' index applied to your own domain: referring domains, anchor text, which links are new and which disappeared. For understanding why your site does or does not have authority, it is the free tool.
A proper site audit
AWT crawls your site the way a search engine would and reports what it found: broken links, redirect chains, missing or duplicated titles and descriptions, slow pages, orphaned pages. Search Console reports some of this, after Google has already encountered it. AWT finds it before.
What AWT will not do is show you anyone else's site. That restriction is the product boundary — it is the free tier of a paid product, and the paid part is competitor data. The rest of the pricing is in Ahrefs pricing explained.
Use them together, in this order
- Set up Search Console first and submit a sitemap. Without it you are guessing about everything.
- Verify the same site in Ahrefs Webmaster Tools and run a full crawl. Fix whatever it finds that is genuinely broken — not every warning is worth acting on.
- Add Bing Webmaster Tools. Ten minutes, and it includes keyword research data that Google does not give away.
- Then read Search Console weekly and AWT monthly. The cadence matters more than the tooling.
That full setup is laid out in the free stack that covers 80%.
What you still cannot see
Being precise about the gap is the point of this article. With both free tools running, you still cannot answer:
- Which keywords is my competitor ranking for that I am not?
- Who links to them and not to me?
- What is the search volume for a keyword I do not yet rank for?
- How hard would it be to rank for it?
Those four questions are the paid product. If you are not yet asking them — because you have thirty pages and a clear idea of what to write next — you do not need to pay. The moment you are choosing between fifty possible articles and need to know which is winnable, you do. The cheapest tools that answer them start at about ₹3,300 a month, not ₹15,000.
Verification, and why it is the whole point
Both tools require you to prove you own the site, and that requirement is what makes them free. They are not giving away competitor intelligence; they are giving you a better view of something that is already yours.
Verify by DNS TXT record where you can. HTML file uploads and meta tags get lost in redesigns and migrations, and losing verification silently loses you history. A DNS record survives a theme change, a host change and a developer leaving.
If you manage client sites, verify them on the client's own account and add yourself as a user. It takes two extra minutes and it means the data stays with the business when the engagement ends.
Common mistakes with both
- Using a URL-prefix property instead of a domain property in Search Console. A domain property covers http, https, www and non-www together. A URL-prefix property silently misses most of your data.
- Submitting a sitemap and never checking it was read. The Sitemaps report shows the last-read date and how many URLs Google found. If that date is weeks old or the count is wrong, nothing downstream is reliable.
- Treating every AWT warning as a bug. A site audit will always find something. Fix broken links, redirect chains and duplicate titles; ignore most of the rest until you have more evidence.
- Requesting indexing instead of fixing the reason. If a page is "Crawled — currently not indexed", Google looked at it and declined. Requesting again does not change its mind; improving the page might.
The report people ignore and should not
Crawl stats, in Search Console's settings. It shows how many requests Googlebot made to your site, what it fetched, and how fast your server answered.
It matters because every other SEO activity assumes Google is visiting. If a 2,000-page site is getting a few dozen crawl requests a day, most of it will simply never be seen, and no amount of title-tag improvement changes that. You would be fixing pages Google has not looked at.
The response-time chart in the same report is the other half. Slow server responses reduce how much Google crawls, which is one of the few places where hosting choices and SEO genuinely touch. If average response time is north of a second, that is worth fixing before anything on the page is.
Setting both up properly, in order
- Search Console, domain property. Verify by DNS TXT record so every protocol and subdomain variant is covered at once. URL-prefix verification is faster and quietly loses you data forever.
- Submit your sitemap, then come back a week later and check the Sitemaps report. It shows the last-read date and the number of URLs Google found. If that number is wrong, nothing downstream can be trusted.
- Ahrefs Webmaster Tools, verified against the same site. Run a full crawl once, then schedule it monthly.
- Bing Webmaster Tools, importing the Search Console property so you skip re-verification.
- Put a 20-minute slot in the calendar weekly. Tools without a habit are decoration.
Reading the two together
The pair is more useful than either alone because they answer adjacent halves of the same question.
When traffic drops, Search Console tells you which queries and pages lost impressions and whether anything fell out of the index. AWT tells you whether the site broke technically, or whether links disappeared, in the same period. One without the other leaves you guessing at the cause.
When a page refuses to rank, Search Console tells you whether Google has even indexed it. AWT tells you whether it is reachable, fast and linked to internally. Between them you can almost always distinguish "Google has not seen this" from "Google has seen it and is not impressed" — and those need opposite responses.
Verdict
Run both. They are not alternatives. Search Console is the only place your real query and indexing data exists. Ahrefs Webmaster Tools is the only free way to see your own link profile with a serious index behind it.
Together they cover a small site's needs almost completely, and they will keep covering them until competitor research becomes the bottleneck. When it does, the decision is in Ahrefs vs Semrush — and for the checks you run from the browser in between, the SEO extensions shortlist costs nothing.
Where to check Ahrefs pricing
Ahrefs — Webmaster Tools is free for sites you own; the paid tiers add competitor data from $29/month. See current pricing.
Frequently asked questions
Is Ahrefs Webmaster Tools really free?
Yes, for sites you own and have verified. It gives a real backlink profile from the Ahrefs index and a full site audit. What it does not give is competitor data — that is the boundary between the free tier and the paid product.
Do I need both Search Console and Ahrefs Webmaster Tools?
They answer different questions, so yes. Search Console is the only source of your real queries, clicks and indexing status. AWT is the only free way to see your own backlink profile with a serious index behind it and to crawl your site like a search engine would.
What can neither free tool tell me?
Three things: which keywords a competitor ranks for that you do not, who links to them and not to you, and the volume and difficulty of a keyword you do not yet rank for. Every paid SEO tool exists to answer those three.
Should I use a domain property in Search Console?
Yes. A domain property covers http, https, www and non-www together. A URL-prefix property silently misses whichever variant you did not add, and people spend months looking at a fraction of their data without noticing.
